(In order of appearance)
| Meg Boyd | Grace Lehman |
| Joe Boyd | Brady Beach |
| Ms. Applegate | Jamie Boyd |
| Sister | Jenessa Provence |
| Doris | Kylie Greaves |
| Joe Hardy | Michael Plummer |
| Van Buren | Timothy Lancia |
| Gloria Thorpe | Lauren Cazares |
| Lois Lynch | Emily Alessio |
| Lola | Stella Mae Coleman |
| Mrs. Welch | Grace Donalson |
| Miss Weston | Madigan Briggs |
| Wives | |
|---|---|
| Karisa | Sarah Krahling |
| Dyana | Tiahana Bible |
| Betty | Madigan Briggs |
| Kathy | Ellie Donalson |
| Tammie | Elizabeth Nichols |
| Linda | Delila Munoz |
| Husbands | |
| Mike | Timothy Lancia |
| Scott | Nathan Massey |
| Tim | Dylan Ryder |
| Mac | Tyler Hicks |
| Andrew | Jack Greenwood |
| Bill | Ryan Urich |
| Washington Senators | |
| Rocky | Dylan Ryder |
| Smokey | Nathan Massey |
| Sohovik | Tyler Hicks |
| Henry | Jack Greenwood |
| Linville | Chloe Prine |
| Vernon | Ryan Urich |
| Mickey | Brady Beach |
| George | Colin Cavanaugh |
| Lou | Eliana Cohen |
| Cal | Abby Sanders |
| Tony | Allyson Muir |
| Herman | Gracey Blaine |
| Reporters | |
| Rhoda | Ellie Donalson |
| Elaine | Elizabeth Nichols |
| Laura | Kira Sutherland |
| Georgia | Delila Munoz |
| Judy | Sophia Palumbo |
| Wendy | Tiahana Bible |
| Kelley | Sarah Krahling |
| Angie | Madigan Briggs |
| Senator Fans | |
| Micki | Delila Munoz |
| Vicki | Kria Sutherland |
| Alexandra | Ellie Donalson |
| Libby | Elizabeth Nichols |
| Debra | Sarah Krahling |
| Betsy | Tiahana Bible |
| Susan | Madigan Briggs |
| Ann | Sophia Palumbo |
| Courtroom | |
| Commissioner | Sophia Pulumbo |
| Postmaster Atkins | Kira Sutherland |
| Guard | |